For the Animals
An Argument Guide
PT

Home / Weak arguments / Exaggeration or attack

V8

"Anemia mostly affects meat eaters."

Exaggeration or attack

They claim more than the evidence supports, or attack people instead of discussing what they do.

Why it is weak

It's a base-rate fallacy: since most people eat meat, most cases of almost anything occur among meat eaters. That doesn't show that meat causes anemia.

And it hides something worth acknowledging: vegetarians and vegans tend to have lower iron stores.

How to say it better

Eating meat doesn't prevent anemia, which is common on every diet. What prevents it is planned eating, with iron sources, vitamin C at meals and tests when needed.

See also